Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jimmy Nicholls's avatar

It's a very reasonable article, of a piece with similarly reasonable articles I've read, mostly on Substack where writers have the most leeway to express themselves without someone else curbing any perceived excess.

But I do think too much ground is given to proponents of gender identity. I can't see that ‘trans women are women’ is true in any sense, nor can I see what it would mean for a male to “feel female”, or how somebody would treat somebody as a woman outside of contexts where sex would be relevant.

Having read your piece, I'm not sure if you see it either. To say, “Trans women are not women in the sense that biological women are, because trans women are not born with female anatomy” seems to concede the entire point, since being an adult with female anatomy is both necessary and sufficient to being a woman. The social stuff is linked, but besides the point.

I agree trans people should be treated with compassion. But it is asking too much to expect us to deny material reality.

Expand full comment
Dalyandot's avatar

What is gender? Feminism used to use gender to mean sex roles, something that is due to socialisation as much as psychology. When did it become an innate essence? Saying you have a gender identity is no more provable than claiming to have an immortal soul. What does feeling like or living as the other sex mean? I have no idea what other women feel or how that is different from men. I have differences and similarities to both men and women. What does living in a gender mean when there are a myriad of ways to live? Does it mean anymore than appearance? These to me are the stumbling blocks. Get rid of gender boxes that we are put into

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts